Appraisal Witness: Qualified Expert

Appraisal Witness: Qualified Expert

Judges opinions about Expert Witnesses

Judges opinions about Expert Witnesses are diverse, opinionated but in most cases valid. The expert appraisal witness must bring technical or scientific skills to the courtroom and will be evaluated by the judge by reference to experience or knowledge in a specific field.

The judge of the case makes the final decision on whether or not to accept the opinion of the expert witness. One of the most famous statements made by a judge qualifying an expert witness is: “…I have a discrete understanding of my limitations, but I also have an understanding of what my experience tells me in having listened for the past 30 years, to appraisers, and while they may not bear all the credentials and all the publications, I have yet to find an appraiser that ever says anything that is cogent and persuasive. Go ahead. I’m always willing to be persuaded.”

Judges cited demeanor, sincerity and body language, as well as careful consideration of evidence. Judges are negatively influenced by aggressive attitude, rude or poor eye contact. Judges look for the ability to explain in clear, consistent simple terms, and qualifications substantiate the expert’s findings without bias.

The appraiser’s report and valuation must reflect real analysis, not simply the appraiser’s ipsi dixit advocacy. “Expert opinions…are no better than the data and the methodology that undergird them.” Id. At 24. An expert will be required to “vouchsafe the reliability of the data on which he relies and explained how the accumulation of that data was consistent with standards of the profession.” Id. Failing to do the homework risks a finding that the “expert testimony offers only a bare conclusion is insufficient to prove the expert’s point.” SMS Systems Maintenance Services, Inc., v. Digital Equipment Corp.

Another judge’s opinion about expert witness clarifies an appraiser’s credentials before he even gets the chance to state them: “I don’t really care about your certifications, although I do appreciate that this is somehow made up by persons who have some professional standing in connection with some effort by the government to improve quality and integrity of appraisals… I’m sure they are all moving, but I really want to know what cases you of appeared in, what books you’ve written or major articles.” J. Bernstein U.S. Bankruptcy Court

The judge in this case said, “an expert opinion is inadmissible if it is connected to existing data only by the ipsi dixit of the expert, for a court may conclude that there is simply too great an analytical gap between the data in the opinion proffered.” General Electric Co. V. Joiner

In commenting to the plaintiff’s attorney, this judge replies, “I absolutely need to know the details of the experts thought process, not simply so your witness can persuade me, but so I can coherently put that analysis into the decision.”

This bankruptcy judge concluded his statements: “…best the valuation of an enterprise… is an exercise in educated guesswork. At worst, it is not much more than crystal ball gazing… it may be that there are better ways to determine value than through courtroom dialectic. That said, the court must work within the system created by Congress and, in valuing the company in Chapter 11, that system contemplates an adversary contest among parties before a neutral judge.” Mirant,et al. Judge D. Michael Lynn of Federal Bankruptcy Court in Fort Worth, Texas

The courts are relying on its participating attorneys to obtain experts that have prepared valuation reports in an unbiased and objective manner concurring with the current state of the appraisal practice. If an expert appraisal witnesses is chosen that cannot fulfill these qualifications the attorneys will suffer the adverse consequences from an excess of vigorous advocacy that impairs the truth seeking duties of the court.

Each week, another case comes to light in which the judge will impeach an expert witness because he or she will fail to complete the simplest of documentation. Each appraisal should be executed as if without a doubt, the appraisal will have to be defended in the court of law. A successful expert witness appraiser must document and use the accepted methodology in every appraisal in order to present evidence to an eventual Court that every care was taken to procure comparables, pictures, valuations, history, and current value influence.

Judges opinions about expert witnesses can be greatly influenced if these simple guidelines are used in the expert witness’ report and all references to the court are provable by the actions listed above and the methodology approved by the Appraisal Commission. In all cases, ipsi dixit (“because I said so”, “believe me because I’ve been in the appraisal business for 30 years”), must never be used to substantiate a valuation, an appraisal or an appraisal report.

Still another judge’s opinion about expert witnesses: To be admissible, expert testimony must be reliable and relevant. The trial judge’s job is to “ensure that an expert’s testimony both rests on a reliable foundation and is relevant to the task at hand.” Daubert v. Merrill Dow Pharms., Inc.

Durkin Valuation Associates have the experience, the current accreditations, and a history of success as expert appraisal witnesses. Call us, (617) 720-0332

Expert Appraisal Witness
  1. (required)
  2. (valid email required)
Please answer the Human verification question.

cforms contact form by delicious:days

Judges opinions about expert witnesses,appraisal witness

Technorati Tags: ,

Be Sociable, Share!

This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at

New England Real Estate Journal Online

IRS final rule cites the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice
New England Real Estate Journal Online
Washington, DC The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has issued a new rule which governs how cash and noncash charitable contributions should be valued. The new rule specifically cites the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) of ...

Tax Court: No Tax Bargain for Charitable Shopping
Other special rules may come into play. Notably, no deduction is generally allowed unless the item is in good condition. In addition, the IRS requires you to obtain an independent appraisal for items valued above $5,000 and to attach the appraisal to ...
Notice 2018-54 -
Pending EO 12866 Regulatory Review -
Four Blue states file suit against Trump administration for tax deduction limitIllinois News Network
Illinois General Assembly
all 28 news articles »

Journal of Accountancy

Final rules govern adequate substantiation for charitable contributions
Journal of Accountancy
The IRS published final regulations that implement changes made by the American Jobs Creation Act of 2004, P.L. 108-357, and the Pension Protection Act of 2006, P.L. 109-280, to the substantiation and reporting rules for charitable contributions under ...

IRS Issues Final Regs on Substantiation and Reporting Requirements for Charitable Contributions
Among other things, the final regulations set forth: (1) the substantiation requirements for contributions of more than $500 under section 170(f)(11)(B) through (D); (2) the new definitions of qualified appraisal and qualified appraiser applicable to ...

New England Real Estate Journal Online

Real estate values achieving all-time highs - Steven Elliott
New England Real Estate Journal Online
I got an e-mail from The Appraisal Foundation informing both practicing appraisers and users of appraisal services that the IRS has, as of July 30, issued a new revised communication entitled, “Substantiation and Reporting Requirements for Cash and ...

Donating a Vehicle to Charity 101
The written appraisal must be from a qualified appraiser. See IRS Publication 561, Determining the Value of Donated Property. The appraisal must be made no more than 60 days before the donation of the vehicle. The appraisal must be received before the ...

Liquid Asset Appraisals Helps Deliver Taxpayer Deductions
PR Web (press release)
Last week, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) issued a new rule regulating how cash and noncash charitable contributions are to be valued. Taxpayers making charitable contributions for tax deduction purposes must use a qualified appraiser conforming to ...

New England Real Estate Journal Online

Durkin's last hurrah! Ways to improve appraisal profession - by Roger Durkin
New England Real Estate Journal Online
FASB is a non-governmental entity like the Appraisal Foundations and Appraisal Standards Board (ASB). Real estate appraisers are federally regulated by the Appraisal Subcommittee ( and to some extent by the IRS (see Notice 2006-96).

Treasury, IRS Issue Final Charitable Contribution Substantiation Regulations
The final regulations supersede and obsolete previous transitional guidance, including Notice 2006-96 (regarding definitions of qualified appraisal/ qualified appraiser); Notice 2006-110 (substantiation of charitable contributions made by payroll); and ...

The Capital Journal

Land that was seized, sold by IRS, sits along entry to city
The Capital Journal
The minimum bid was set by the IRS at $31,566, a number that's tied to the fair market value of the property, according to Deborah Evenson, the property appraisal and liquidation specialist for the IRS who handled the auction. Evenson told the Capital ...

Google News

Copyright © 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012 All rights reserved.